Melendez or Ishida?

[carbondioxide830]

i saw this fight recently and i cant help but think gilbert melendez should still be undefeated. those who have seen the fight, what do you think?

[lovebuzzkurt]

Originally Posted by carbondioxide830

i saw this fight recently and i cant help but think gilbert melendez should still be undefeated. those who have seen the fight, what do you think?

Dude Ishida was like white on rice on melendez in that fight, he had control most of the fight from my recollection. I remember thinking it was an accurate decision .

[Intellectual]

i watched the fight, wasn't the most spectacular. i dont remember disagreeing with the decision. all i remember was Ishida controlling every aspect of the fight.

[Brutus]

Originally Posted by Dr. Leg Lock

i watched the fight, wasn't the most spectacular. i dont remember disagreeing with the decision. all i remember was Ishida controlling every aspect of the fight.

pretty much my thoughts. Melendez is one of my favorite fighters and if i remember correctly, assuming my brain wasnt clouded by malted hops and bong resin, i was very disappointed the entire fight.

[ricklo19]

Ishida took this one for sure...accordingly Melendez, he felt like Ishida was just wrestling....but if you watched it...i say he was out-wrestled...they should have a rematch I guess....